• 亿邦公众号
    • APP下载

胖东来洗发水事件背后:商业责任边界该如何厘清?

作者:联商网 文章来源:联商网

2026-11-16 08:58

作者:联商网 文章来源:联商网

2026-11-16 08:58

邦小白快读

EN
全文速览

总1:事件脉络与核心结论。

1.卡蓓诺被质疑产地造假、假洋牌后,胖东来成立专项组,先查广州平辰,再赴日本科思美碧优蒂总部,核对报关单、入境检验检疫证明、原产地证明和批次检验记录,确认产品为日本生产进口。

2.11月8日胖东来公开全部核查证据并启动法律维权,相关民事诉讼已于11月6日立案;舆论焦点后来从产地转向品牌血统。

3.核心争议不是产品有剧毒或违禁成分,而是品牌血统与营销故事存在信息差:卡蓓诺中国商标2016年11月注册,日本同名商标由平辰2019年申请、2020年拿下,在日本主流渠道难觅,抖音旗舰店据媒体报道11月10日关闭。

总2:消费者可用的判断方法。

1.看跨境商品是否属于国内公司持商标、海外工厂代工、专供中国市场,不能只看“日本生产进口”就等同于日本本土大牌。

2.关注商标注册地、实际销售渠道和宣传口径;零售商做不到全项化学盲测,但应事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底。

3.胖东来已承诺即便万一有问题也拿出让顾客满意的解决方案,并称质疑是鞭策,会强化品控管理。

总1:品牌叙事与信任边界。

1.借海外代工厂资质包装异国情调,商业上不违法,但有意无意模糊本土品牌与海外代工界限、误导消费者,会透支市场信任。

2.品牌方必须对商标注册、品牌定位和宣传口径承担第一责任,真实叙事是品牌营销的底线。

总2:消费趋势与用户行为观察。

1.消费者对产地、品牌血统和渠道透明度高度敏感,“以为是日本本土大牌、结果像贴牌”的落差会迅速转化为质疑。

2.日本主流渠道难觅、抖音旗舰店关闭等信息会放大不信任,说明渠道建设与营销故事必须相互印证。

总3:品牌渠道与风险应对。

1.跨境商品常见模式是国内公司持商标、海外工厂代工、专供中国市场,品牌商应主动说明代工关系和商标归属。

2.出现争议时要公开核查证据、法律维权、透明沟通;胖东来不删帖、不冷处理、成立专项组溯源、公开完整报告的做法,可作为品牌风险应对参考。

总1:事件应对的可学习点。

1.胖东来在1月质疑初起即成立专项组,赴广州贸易商和日本工厂核查报关单、检疫证明、原产地证明、批次记录;11月6日诉讼立案,11月8日公开全部证据。

2.11月13日再成立专项工作团队,承诺即便万一有问题也给顾客满意方案;11月14日称人红是非多,把质疑当鞭策,该改进认真修正、该解释坦诚说明。

3.处理争议不删帖、不冷处理,形成企业回应、专项组溯源、公开完整调研报告的透明机制。

总2:风险提示与机会提示。

1.风险在于跨境商品存在品牌血统信息差:国内商标持有、海外代工、专供中国市场,若宣传模糊边界,会引发产地和假洋牌质疑。

2.机会在于建立透明供应链和完整证据链,用真实标注、渠道透明和快速回应重建信任;零售商要守住事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底。

总3:商业模式与合作方式。

1.品牌方管好品牌故事,工厂守住品质底线,零售商负责合规查验和首问兜底,责任分层比互相推诿更可持续。

2.卖家可借鉴胖东来的正面应对,同时警惕上游营销包装瑕疵带来的舆论风险。

总1:生产端责任与品质底线。

1.文章核查显示,卡蓓诺由日本代工厂科思美碧优蒂及其旗下工厂生产,产品确系日本生产进口,具备合规的物理和化学出厂标准。

2.制造端的核心责任是确保原料配方、生产批次稳定安全,不偷工减料;品牌营销故事的真伪不应由工厂独自承担。

总2:商业机会与代工模式。

1.国内公司持有商标、海外工厂代工、专供中国市场的跨境商品模式存在商业机会,代工厂可承接品牌方的生产需求。

2.但代工关系与商标归属需要清晰披露,不能借海外工厂资质模糊本土品牌与海外代工的界限。

总3:数字化和电商启示。

1.渠道透明直接影响消费者信任:卡蓓诺在日本乐天、LIPS、cosme等主流渠道难觅,抖音旗舰店关闭,说明线上渠道信息会被快速核查和放大。

2.工厂应配合提供报关单、原产地证明、批次检验记录等证据链,便于零售商溯源和平台展示,降低信息差风险。

总1:客户痛点。

1.零售商面对几万个SKU,无法对每批洗发水做全项化学盲测,也难以对每个供应商做深度法律和资产溯源,自建实验室做破坏性检测会拖垮流通效率并转嫁成本。

2.品牌方存在商标注册、品牌定位和宣传口径的真实叙事责任;监管对特殊化妆品注册与进口单证主要核验产地资质,不审查品牌故事,形成合规但信息差的空白。

总2:解决方案。

1.帮助客户建立透明化争议处理机制:事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底;出现质疑后成立专项组,赴上游工厂和贸易商核查报关单、检疫证明、原产地证明和批次记录。

2.用公开证据、法律维权、完整调研报告和不删帖不冷处理的姿态回应舆论,必要时承诺顾客满意方案。

总3:行业趋势。

1.全球化复杂供应链下,头部零售企业也会遭遇上游信息差暗礁,供应链溯源、合规审核、舆情应对和证据链管理会成为服务需求。

2.零售业正在形成高度透明化机制,服务商可围绕品牌血统核验、渠道披露和风险预警提供支持。

总1:商业对平台的需求和问题。

1.零售商需要上游品牌方提供真实的商标注册信息、品牌定位、宣传口径,以及报关单、入境检验检疫证明、原产地证明、批次检验记录等证据。

2.消费者对品牌血统和渠道信息差敏感,平台或商超如果只做单证审核,难以覆盖营销故事与实际流通路径不一致的问题。

总2:平台最新做法和运营管理。

1.胖东来形成不删帖、不冷处理、企业回应、成立专项组溯源、向社会公开完整调研报告的机制;先诉讼立案再公开证据,并承诺万一有问题给顾客满意方案。

2.运营管理上要把事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底作为底线,同时用透明自查替消费者向上游较真。

总3:招商与风向规避。

1.招商时应要求品牌方明确商标持有者、代工关系、实际销售渠道,避免本土品牌伪装海外大牌。

2.对国内公司持商标、海外工厂代工、专供中国市场的跨境商品,应强化信息披露;风向规避上不要把上游营销包装瑕疵全部归责零售商,避免逆向淘汰。

总1:产业新动向与新问题。

1.卡蓓诺事件显示跨境商品出现国内公司持商标、海外工厂代工、专供中国市场的新模式;争议从产地真假转向品牌血统和营销故事,说明供应链信息差正成为零售业新风险。

2.即便头部零售企业追求极致,也难完全穿透上游品牌包装,合规单证与消费者认知之间可能长期存在落差。

总2:商业模式与责任边界。

1.品牌方对商标注册、品牌定位、宣传口径承担第一责任;制造端守住原料配方和批次品质;零售商承担事前资质查验、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底,不能要求其做全知全能的质检局。

2.监管对特殊化妆品注册与进口单证主要核验产地与资质,不审查品牌故事,形成合规却存在信息差的监管空白。

总3:政策法规建议和启示。

1.可研究强化品牌注册信息、代工关系和渠道披露的透明度,减少本土品牌与海外代工之间的认知误导。

2.建立零售争议透明处理机制:专项调查、公开证据、法律维权、完整报告和顾客兜底;同时避免对真诚者逆向淘汰,让制造者、品牌方、零售商各担其责。

声明:快读内容全程由AI生成,请注意甄别信息。如您发现问题,请发送邮件至 run@ebrun.com 。

我是 品牌商 卖家 工厂 服务商 平台商 研究者 帮我再读一遍。

Quick Summary

Summary 1: Event timeline and core conclusions.

1. After Kabeno was questioned over origin fraud and being a fake foreign brand, Pang Dong Lai set up a special task force. It first inspected Guangzhou Pingchen, then went to the Japan headquarters of Cosme Biyuti to cross-check customs declarations, inbound inspection and quarantine certificates, certificates of origin, and batch inspection records, confirming that the products were manufactured and imported from Japan.

2. On November 8, Pang Dong Lai disclosed all verification evidence and initiated legal action; the related civil lawsuit was filed on November 6. Public attention later shifted from origin to brand lineage.

3. The core dispute is not that the product contains toxic or prohibited ingredients, but an information gap between the brand lineage and its marketing story: Kabeno's China trademark was registered in November 2016; the Japanese trademark of the same name was applied for by Pingchen in 2019 and secured in 2020; the brand is hard to find in mainstream Japanese channels; and its Douyin flagship store was reported closed on November 10.

Summary 2: Judgment methods available to consumers.

1. Check whether a cross-border product is trademarked by a domestic company, manufactured by an overseas factory as an OEM, and sold only to the Chinese market; do not equate 'manufactured and imported from Japan' with a major Japanese domestic brand.

2. Pay attention to where the trademark is registered, actual sales channels, and marketing claims; retailers cannot conduct full chemical blind tests, but they should rigorously vet qualifications beforehand, manage compliance during the process, and take first point of contact accountability afterward.

3. Pang Dong Lai has promised to provide a solution that satisfies customers even if a problem ultimately emerges, and said it treats the questioning as a spur to strengthen quality control.

Summary 1: Brand narrative and the boundaries of trust.

1. Packaging a domestic brand with the qualifications of an overseas OEM to create an exotic image is not illegal commercially, but deliberately or inadvertently blurring the line between a domestic brand and overseas OEM production misleads consumers and erodes market trust.

2. The brand owner must bear primary responsibility for trademark registration, brand positioning, and marketing claims; truthful storytelling is the bottom line of brand marketing.

Summary 2: Consumer trends and user behavior.

1. Consumers are highly sensitive to origin, brand lineage, and channel transparency; the gap between 'believed to be a major Japanese brand' and 'looks like an OEM label' quickly turns into suspicion.

2. Information such as the brand being hard to find in mainstream Japanese channels and the closure of its Douyin flagship store amplifies distrust, showing that channel development and marketing stories must corroborate each other.

Summary 3: Brand channels and risk response.

1. A common model for cross-border products is domestic trademark ownership, overseas OEM production, and exclusive sales to the Chinese market; brands should proactively disclose OEM relationships and trademark ownership.

2. When a dispute arises, they should disclose verification evidence, pursue legal action, and communicate transparently; Pang Dong Lai's approach—not deleting posts, not handling the matter passively, setting up a task force for traceability, and publishing a complete report—can serve as a reference for brand risk response.

Summary 1: Lessons from the response.

1. When doubts first emerged in January, Pang Dong Lai set up a special task force and sent staff to the Guangzhou trader and the Japanese factory to verify customs declarations, quarantine certificates, certificates of origin, and batch records; the lawsuit was filed on November 6, and all evidence was disclosed on November 8.

2. On November 13, it set up another dedicated task team and promised a satisfactory solution for customers even if a problem were found; on November 14, it said that prominence invites scrutiny, treating questions as a spur to improve where needed and explain candidly where necessary.

3. It did not delete posts or handle the controversy passively, creating a transparent mechanism of corporate response, task-force traceability, and public release of complete investigation reports.

Summary 2: Risk and opportunity.

1. The risk is the brand-lineage information gap in cross-border products: domestic trademark ownership, overseas OEM production, and exclusive sales to the Chinese market. If marketing blurs these boundaries, it can trigger questions about origin and fake foreign brands.

2. The opportunity is to build a transparent supply chain and a complete evidence chain, rebuilding trust through truthful labeling, channel transparency, and rapid response; retailers must maintain rigorous pre-vetting of qualifications, compliance management during the process, and first point of contact accountability afterward.

Summary 3: Business model and cooperation.

1. Brand owners should manage the brand story, factories should uphold the quality bottom line, and retailers should be responsible for compliance verification and first point of contact accountability; layered responsibility is more sustainable than finger-pointing.

2. Sellers can learn from Pang Dong Lai's proactive response while remaining alert to reputational risk from flaws in upstream marketing packaging.

Summary 1: Production-side responsibility and quality bottom line.

1. The article's verification shows that Kabeno is produced by the Japanese OEM Cosme Biyuti and its affiliated factories; the products are indeed manufactured and imported from Japan and meet compliant physical and chemical factory standards.

2. The core responsibility of the manufacturing side is to ensure stable and safe raw materials, formulations, and production batches without cutting corners; the authenticity of the brand marketing story should not be borne by the factory alone.

Summary 2: Business opportunities and the OEM model.

1. The cross-border product model—domestic trademark ownership, overseas factory OEM production, and exclusive sales to the Chinese market—presents business opportunities, and OEM factories can take on brand owners' production needs.

2. However, OEM relationships and trademark ownership need to be clearly disclosed; overseas factory qualifications should not be used to blur the line between domestic brands and overseas OEM production.

Summary 3: Digital and e-commerce implications.

1. Channel transparency directly affects consumer trust: Kabeno is hard to find in mainstream Japanese channels such as Rakuten, LIPS, and cosme, and its Douyin flagship store has closed, showing that online channel information can be quickly verified and amplified.

2. Factories should cooperate by providing customs declarations, certificates of origin, batch inspection records, and other evidence-chain documents to facilitate retailer traceability and platform display, reducing information-gap risk.

Summary 1: Client pain points.

1. Retailers facing tens of thousands of SKUs cannot conduct full chemical blind tests on every batch of shampoo, nor can they conduct deep legal and asset traceability on every supplier; building in-house laboratories for destructive testing would cripple distribution efficiency and pass costs downstream.

2. Brand owners bear the responsibility for truthful storytelling in trademark registration, brand positioning, and marketing claims; regulators mainly verify origin and qualifications for special cosmetics registrations and import documents, not brand stories, creating a compliance gap filled by information asymmetry.

Summary 2: Solutions.

1. Help clients establish transparent dispute-handling mechanisms: rigorous pre-vetting of qualifications, compliance management during the process, and first point of contact accountability afterward; after doubts arise, set up a task force and verify customs declarations, quarantine certificates, certificates of origin, and batch records with upstream factories and traders.

2. Respond to public opinion with public evidence, legal action, complete investigation reports, and a stance of not deleting posts or handling matters passively, promising a customer-satisfaction solution when necessary.

Summary 3: Industry trends.

1. Under complex global supply chains, even leading retailers can encounter upstream information-gap reefs; supply-chain traceability, compliance review, public-opinion response, and evidence-chain management will become service demand.

2. Retail is developing highly transparent mechanisms, and service providers can offer support around brand-lineage verification, channel disclosure, and risk alerts.

Summary 1: Business needs and problems for platforms.

1. Retailers need upstream brand owners to provide truthful trademark registration information, brand positioning, and marketing claims, as well as customs declarations, inbound inspection and quarantine certificates, certificates of origin, and batch inspection records.

2. Consumers are sensitive to brand lineage and channel information gaps; if platforms or supermarkets only review documents, they can hardly cover the mismatch between marketing stories and actual distribution paths.

Summary 2: Latest platform practices and operational management.

1. Pang Dong Lai has established a mechanism of not deleting posts, not handling matters passively, corporate response, task-force traceability, and public release of complete investigation reports; it filed the lawsuit before disclosing evidence and promised a satisfactory solution if a problem were found.

2. In operations, rigorous pre-vetting, compliance management during the process, and first point of contact accountability should be the bottom line, while transparent self-inspection can help consumers hold upstream parties accountable.

Summary 3: Merchant recruitment and risk avoidance.

1. During merchant recruitment, brand owners should be required to clarify trademark ownership, OEM relationships, and actual sales channels to prevent domestic brands from masquerading as major overseas brands.

2. For cross-border products with domestic trademark ownership, overseas OEM production, and exclusive sales to the Chinese market, information disclosure should be strengthened; in risk avoidance, upstream marketing-packaging flaws should not be entirely blamed on retailers, to avoid adverse selection.

Summary 1: New industry dynamics and issues.

1. The Kabeno case reveals a new cross-border product model: domestic trademark ownership, overseas factory OEM production, and exclusive sales to the Chinese market. The controversy shifted from origin authenticity to brand lineage and marketing stories, indicating that supply-chain information gaps are becoming a new risk for retail.

2. Even leading retailers pursuing excellence cannot fully penetrate upstream brand packaging, and a gap may persist between compliant documents and consumer perception.

Summary 2: Business model and responsibility boundaries.

1. Brand owners bear primary responsibility for trademark registration, brand positioning, and marketing claims; manufacturers should uphold raw-material formulations and batch quality; retailers should undertake pre-qualification verification, in-process compliance management, and post-event first point of contact accountability, and should not be required to act as all-knowing quality inspection authorities.

2. Regulators mainly verify origin and qualifications for special cosmetics registrations and import documents, not brand stories, creating a regulatory gap where compliance exists but information asymmetry remains.

Summary 3: Policy and regulatory recommendations and implications.

1. Research could strengthen transparency in brand registration information, OEM relationships, and channel disclosure to reduce cognitive misleading between domestic brands and overseas OEM production.

2. Establish transparent retail dispute-handling mechanisms: dedicated investigations, public evidence, legal action, complete reports, and customer backstop; at the same time, avoid adverse selection against sincere actors, so that manufacturers, brands, and retailers each bear their own responsibility.

Disclaimer: The "Quick Summary" content is entirely generated by AI. Please exercise discretion when interpreting the information. For issues or corrections, please email run@ebrun.com .

I am a Brand Seller Factory Service Provider Marketplace Seller Researcher Read it again.

近期,胖东来因为一款名为“卡蓓诺(CABELO)”的洗发水,又一次被推上了舆论的风口浪尖。

从网上的各种质疑,到创始人于东来公开表态成立专项调查组、承诺给出详尽报告,再到此前胖东来跨海赴日溯源,甚至诉诸法律,这件事情可以说一波三折。

今天的胖东来,是不是被架在了一个过于苛刻的“完美主义火炉”上?当一件商品出现争议时,零售商的责任边界到底在哪?

01 显微镜之下的审视

要想看清这场风波,首先得明白胖东来现在面临的舆论环境。

正因为今天的胖东来影响力太大、美誉度太高,公众对它的心理预期发生了一种微妙的异化:大家不再把它当成一家“优秀的超市”,而是把它当成了一个“永远不会出错的圣人”。

在互联网的放大镜下,普通商超卖出一件有争议的商品,大家顶多找售后退货;但只要胖东来的货架上出现任何一点风吹草动,哪怕这个锅根本不该由零售商来背,舆论的板子也会毫不犹豫地抽过去。

先把这件事的来龙去脉简要捋一遍。

质疑并非这次才有:2026年1月,网上就零星出现过卡蓓诺“产地造假、假洋牌”的说法,胖东来当即成立专项调查小组,先赴中国贸易商广州平辰现场调查。

同月飞赴日本科思美碧优蒂总部实地溯源,逐项核对报关单、入境检验检疫证明、原产地证明和批次检验记录,确认产品确系日本生产进口;当时舆论未大范围发酵,全套材料封存备作法律证据。

11月7日,质疑视频再度流出并被迅速放大;11月8日,胖东来一次性公开全部核查证据,并宣布启动法律维权——针对不实信息的民事诉讼已于11月6日立案,比视频集中爆发还早一天;平辰贸易的另案诉讼定于12月10日开庭。

此后,随着媒体深挖,舆论焦点从“产地”悄悄转向“血统”:“卡蓓诺”商标2016年11月在中国注册,日本的同名商标也是平辰贸易2019年申请、2020年拿下的,而这个品牌在乐天、LIPS、cosme等日本主流渠道难觅其踪,卡蓓诺抖音旗舰店据媒体报道已于11月10日关闭。

11月13日晚,于东来宣布成立专项工作团队展开更详细调查,承诺“即便是万一有问题,也会拿出让顾客满意的解决方案”;11月14日再回应“人红是非多”,称这是鞭策,倒逼企业强化品控管理。

在这样的脉络里看,这次风波的核心争议,并不是产品本身有剧毒或者用了违禁化学成分,而是它的“品牌血统与营销故事”和实际流通路径之间存在信息差。

产品确实是日本代工厂科思美碧优蒂及其旗下工厂生产的,也是从日本原装进口的,但它的商标早在2016年11月就被国内贸易商(广州平辰贸易)注册了。

说白了,它更像是一个“国内公司持有商标、海外工厂代工生产、专供中国市场”的跨境商品。

当这个商业细节被扒出来后,消费者觉得:“我以为买的是日本本土大牌,结果是个‘贴牌’,胖东来你是不是把关不严?”

这就是胖东来面临的尴尬:它用极致的真诚赢得了消费者的信任,而当下遇到上游供应链复杂的商业包装,怎么办?

02 各方的责任到底在哪?

要给公众一个理性的视角,我们就必须把商品从工厂到货架的链条拆开,看看各方究竟该承担什么责任。

这就好比前阵子闹得沸沸扬扬的“药水泡杨梅”事件,社区水果店按常规流程进货,根本无法知晓内部的化学残留。同理,洗发水也是一样:

1.品牌方与商标持有者:讲故事的边界在哪?

卡蓓诺的幕后操盘方,需要承担的是“真实叙事”的责任。

在激烈的市场竞争中,借助海外代工厂的资质来包装一个具有异国情调的品牌,虽然在商业上并不违法,但如果在营销中有意无意地误导消费者、模糊“本土品牌”与“海外代工”的界限,就是在透支整个市场的信任。

品牌方必须对自己的商标注册、品牌定位以及宣传口径承担第一责任。

2.生产制造端:物理品质的底线

日本的代工厂负责的是生产环节。从目前的核查来看,产品本身确实是正规工厂生产的,具备合规的物理和化学出厂标准。

制造端的核心责任在于确保每一瓶洗发水的原料配方、生产批次稳定安全,不偷工减料。

3.终端零售商(胖东来):它能做“全知全能的质检局”吗?

这正是我们要重点探讨的核心:胖东来作为一个零售商,责任边界到底在哪?

4.监管层的“监管空白”

特殊化妆品注册与进口单证审核主要核验产地与资质,并不审查品牌故事,这种“合规却存在信息差”的监管空白,正是争议滋生的土壤。

很多人觉得,既然你在胖东来买的,胖东来就得负全责。从法理和现代商业分工来看,这种要求是不现实的。

第一,商超做不到“全项化学盲测”。一家大卖场有几万个SKU,涵盖日化、生鲜、百货。

如果要求零售商对每一批次洗发水的微量元素、每一个供应商的品牌注册史都去做深度的法律和资产溯源,甚至自建实验室对所有商品做破坏性检测,那么现代零售的流通效率瞬间就会瘫痪,最终所有的成本只能转嫁到消费者头上。

第二,胖东来已经做到了“合规查验的极致”。回顾这次事件,胖东来并不是出了事才慌乱推卸。早在今年1月质疑声刚露头时,胖东来就成立了专项组,甚至直接飞到日本去查人家的工厂、海关报关单和检验检疫证明。

11月6日,胖东来称已就相关不实信息提起民事诉讼并获立案;11月8日,公开晒出所有硬核证据;11月13日晚,于东来表态成立专项组,并承诺“即便万一有问题也会拿出让顾客满意的解决方案”。

11月14日,于东来再度表示,这件事是鞭策,倒逼企业强化品控管理,处理质疑就两件事——该改进的认真修正,该解释的坦诚说明。‌‌

从这些动作可以看出,胖东来在零售商的边界上,不仅守住了“事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底”的法律底线,甚至还向前多走了好几步——用透明的自查和不推诿的姿态,替消费者去和上游供应商死磕。

03 别让真诚者寒心

剖析胖东来洗发水事件,是为了我们的消费不会被一种“逆向淘汰”的氛围带偏。

如果公众和舆论对胖东来的要求,已经苛刻到“只要上游有一点点营销包装的瑕疵,就要把零售商打入十八层地狱”。

如果一家愿意主动飞去日本查工厂、愿意掏真金白银起诉涉事方、愿意公开所有调查报告的企业,反而因为坦诚而被骂得最惨,那么其他零售企业看到会怎么想?

如果零售业退回到那个互相推诿、明哲保身,谁也不愿为消费者较真的年代,那才是中国消费者的最大损失。

2024年“擀面皮加工卫生事件”:胖东来没有遮掩,主动公布详细调查情况,对涉事商户及内部管理人员严肃处理,对发现重大食品安全隐患的顾客奖励10万元,并为相关时段购买顾客办理退款、补偿金额883.3万元,树立了极高的自我纠错标准。

2025年“红色内裤掉色过敏风波”:胖东来成立专项调查小组,最终发布一份长达数十页、涵盖检测报告、采购链路与时间线的详尽调查报告,既向公众还原了商品合格的客观事实,也对不实指控启动了法律追责。

2025年“玉石品质与毛利率质疑风波”:胖东来选择直接公开相关品类的销售数据、毛利率水平及权威鉴定逻辑,接受市场监督部门与公众的全面核查。

经历多次舆论风暴后,胖东来在处理供应链与商品争议时,已形成高度透明化的机制——不删帖、不冷处理、企业回应、成立专项组溯源、向社会公开完整调研报告。

写在最后

胖东来的洗发水风波,给整个中国零售业上了一堂深刻的风险课。它告诉我们:在高度复杂的全球化供应链面前,即便是像胖东来这样追求极致的头部企业,也难免会遭遇上游信息差带来的“暗礁”。

但比“遇到问题”更重要的,是“面对问题的态度”。胖东来没有选择删帖冷处理,没有选择遮遮掩掩,而是把底牌全盘托出,交给法律和时间去公正裁决。

同时从某种意义上而言,也正是这样一次次的考验,在一次次帮助胖东来查漏补缺,变得越来越纯粹,也越来越赢得社会的信任。

让制造者承担制造的责任,让品牌方管好品牌的故事,让零售商守住真诚与兜底的底线,这才是用理性的眼光去看清商业逻辑。

给真诚者多一点空间,给实干者多一点宽容。这,才是中国商业走向成熟应有的体面与理性。

注:文/联商网,文章来源:联商网(公众号ID:linkshop2012),本文为作者独立观点,不代表亿邦动力立场。

【版权提示】亿邦动力倡导尊重与保护知识产权。未经许可,任何人不得复制、转载、或以其他方式使用本网站的内容。如发现本站文章存在版权问题,烦请提供版权疑问、身份证明、版权证明、联系方式等发邮件至run@ebrun.com,我们将及时沟通与处理。

已点赞

+1

{{ praise_text }}

好文章,值得被更多人看到

FAQ回顾

卡蓓诺洗发水为什么引发品牌血统争议?

争议核心不是产品质量或违禁成分,而是品牌血统与营销故事同实际流通路径存在信息差。卡蓓诺确由日本科思美碧优蒂代工并原装进口,但中国商标2016年11月由广州平辰贸易注册,日本同名商标也由其2019年申请、2020年取得,且在日本主流渠道难觅,被质疑为“国内持标、海外代工、专供中国”的跨境商品。

零售商需要为上游品牌的营销包装承担全部责任吗?

零售商难以承担全部责任。大型商超有数万个SKU,无法对每批次商品做全项化学盲测,也难以深度溯源每个供应商的品牌注册史,否则流通效率会瘫痪、成本转嫁消费者。零售商应守住事前严查资质、事中合规管理、事后首问兜底的底线;品牌方对商标注册和宣传口径负第一责任,制造端对品质安全负责。

胖东来如何处理商品质疑和供应链争议?

胖东来已形成透明化处理机制:不删帖、不冷处理,企业回应、成立专项组溯源、公开完整调研报告。卡蓓诺事件中,2026年1月质疑出现后即成立专项组,赴广州平辰和日本科思美碧优蒂核查报关单、检疫证明、原产地证明及批次记录;11月6日就相关不实信息提起民事诉讼并获立案,11月8日公开核查证据,11月13日再设专项团队承诺兜底。

“国内商标+海外代工”的跨境商品模式存在哪些风险?

这种模式在商业上并不违法,但风险在于营销中若模糊“本土品牌”与“海外代工”的界限,容易让消费者误以为买到日本本土大牌,形成信息差并透支市场信任。同时,监管主要核验产地与资质,不审查品牌故事,合规却存在信息差的空白会成为争议滋生土壤。品牌方需对商标注册、品牌定位和宣传口径承担第一责任。

胖东来过往商品风波的处理方式对零售行业有什么启示?

胖东来的做法提供了透明化样本:2024年擀面皮加工卫生事件中主动公布调查、奖励发现隐患顾客10万元,并为相关顾客退款补偿883.3万元;2025年红色内裤、玉石争议中公开检测报告、采购链路、销售数据和毛利率,接受核查并对不实指控追责。零售企业应守住真诚与兜底底线,避免让愿意较真者因坦诚被逆向淘汰。

广告

下一篇

征集报名《品牌数字化服务商资源手册》

《品牌数字化服务商资源手册》展示数字化服务商风采,亿邦全年零售大会通发,触达更多资源,马上加入!

马上入驻

11月16日电商早报:京东双11收官服务订单超3亿;小红书AI赛道又落一子

京东双11收官服务订单超3亿;小红书AI赛道又落一子

生鲜 海外仓 营销 叮咚买菜

2026-11-16 06:35:39