• 亿邦公众号
    • APP下载

无招的瓜快吃完了 但钉钉真正的挑战 才刚刚开始

作者:戴珂 文章来源:tobesaas

2026-06-30 15:27

作者:戴珂 文章来源:tobesaas

2026-06-30 15:27

邦小白快读

EN
全文速览

总:这篇文章拆解了钉钉经历无招离职风波后的真实处境,梳理了钉钉三代负责人的发展路径,指出钉钉真正的深层挑战才刚刚开始,核心干货如下

1. 发展历程梳理:第一次由无招带队,从管理者视角切入办公赛道,抓住管理者是付费决策人的核心,在一众同类产品中成功突围,但这套打法仅适配中小微企业,对大型集团适配性差,存在天生定位局限。

2. 路径变更梳理:第二代负责人不穷接手后,将钉钉从单一办公工具升级为企业服务平台,搭建好了SaaS生态雏形,但还未打磨成熟就因不穷卸任,生态建设被迫暂停。

3. 当前现状梳理:无招回归后推倒原有业务和生态布局,全面转向AI推出悟空AI,但因舍弃过往积累缺少业务底座支撑,多数业务场景落地困难,随后无招再度离职,目前新负责人搭建了新组织架构,但修复断层重建生态仍需漫长时间,核心痛点是发展阶段断层、缺乏延续性,每次提速冲刺都很快被迫踩刹车。

总:本文对钉钉发展的全路径复盘,能给ToB领域品牌商带来很多关于定位、布局、转型的启发,核心干货如下

1. 品牌定位层面:钉钉早年跳出同质化竞争,独辟蹊径从管理者视角切入,抓住管理者是付费买单决策人的核心,成功从一众办公软件中突围,这种精准击中决策人的定位思路值得品牌商参考;同时也要注意定位的局限性,钉钉这套打法仅适配中小微企业,大型客户适配性差,品牌定位要提前明确覆盖人群的边界。

2. 生态布局层面:SaaS生态商业模式的增长空间巨大,成熟SaaS生态可做到平台每赚1元,生态伙伴能赚到6至8元,按照这个模型测算,钉钉生态成熟后整体收入可突破200亿,但生态建设是慢工出细活,需要长期持续投入,不能中途中断建设。

3. AI转型层面:AI转型不能脱离原有业务和生态积累,不合理的KPI考核会误导业务方向,品牌做AI转型要避免设置不符合业务逻辑的考核指标。

总:本文分析钉钉发展过程中的经验与教训,对布局企业服务赛道的卖家有很多参考、提示,核心干货如下

1. 可借鉴的经验:创业初期要找准付费决策人定位,钉钉抓住管理者是付费买单方这个核心,成功从同质化竞争中突围,这个切入点值得初创卖家参考;搭建开放生态能放大整体收入规模,成熟生态可以实现平台1元收入带动伙伴6-8元收入,长期增长空间充足。

2. 需要警惕的风险:企业发展要保持战略延续性,核心负责人变动带来的频繁战略调整,推倒重来会中断前期积累,拖慢整体发展节奏;不合理的KPI考核会误导业务方向,比如钉钉把Token消耗量纳入AI业务考核,反而导致AI业务空心化落地难,要避免设置不符合业务逻辑的考核指标。

3. AI转型提示:AI落地需要原有业务系统和生态做底座支撑,脱离底座从零做AI很难适配大多数业务场景,转型不能盲目舍弃原有积累,要平衡新业务和旧积累的关系。

总:本文分析钉钉作为企业服务工具的发展问题,能给推进数字化转型的工厂带来不少启发,核心干货如下

1. 数字化工具选型启示:钉钉不同发展阶段的定位不同,早年偏向管理者管理需求,更适配中小微团队,对大型企业适配性较差,工厂在选型数字化管理工具时,要结合自身规模、业务需求判断适配性,不要盲目选择不符合自身发展阶段的产品。

2. 智能化转型落地启示:工厂做AI智能化转型,不能脱离原有业务系统底座,任何AI场景落地都需要现有生产、供应链、ERP、售后等各个业务系统联动支撑,脱离原有业务积累盲目从零做AI转型,很难落地见效,甚至会浪费前期投入。

3. 战略推进启示:数字化、智能化建设是长期工程,需要保持战略延续性,持续投入深耕,频繁中断战略、更换发展方向会导致前期投入浪费,难以拿到预期成果,工厂推进转型要做好长期投入的准备,保持战略稳定。

总:本文梳理了钉钉发展历程和当前企业服务行业的动向,对ToB企业服务服务商有不少参考价值,核心干货如下

1. 当前行业发展动向:AI原生转型是当前企业服务赛道的核心方向,头部平台都在发力AI产品,但转型过程中存在普遍痛点,很多头部平台转型脱离原有生态和业务底座,导致AI产品落地难,市场存在大量未被满足的需求。

2. 可挖掘的客户痛点:现在企业客户的AI转型需求旺盛,但AI落地需要多业务系统联动支撑,缺少生态配套的头部平台无法满足这类需求,服务商可以依托自身垂直领域的业务系统能力,对接头部平台补齐生态短板,解决客户AI落地的痛点。

3. 合作发展启示:SaaS生态是未来成熟的商业模式,长期价值巨大,成熟生态可以达到平台1元收入带动伙伴6-8元收入的水平,服务商和头部平台合作能获得更大的收入增长空间,不过生态建设需要慢工出细活,要做好长期深耕的准备。

总:本文分析钉钉发展过程中的经验教训,对做企业服务平台的平台商有很多战略、运营层面的参考,核心干货如下

1. 战略规划层面:平台发展要保持战略延续性,钉钉经历三次核心负责人变更,三次大幅调整战略,中断了SaaS生态的持续建设,导致发展出现断层,每次提速冲刺都很快被迫踩刹车,平台要避免频繁推倒原有战略,要重视过往积累的延续性,不要轻易否定全部原有布局。

2. 运营考核层面:要设置符合业务规律的KPI指标,钉钉早年背负不合理的阿里云资源消耗量考核,导致无效客户过多,付费率持续低迷至今未修复;现在又把Token消耗量纳入AI业务考核,不符合AI落地的业务逻辑,反而导致AI业务空心化,平台考核一定要贴合业务本质,避免设置错误的考核指标带偏业务方向。

3. AI转型层面:AI转型不能脱离原有业务底座和生态建设,要依托成熟的生态伙伴业务系统支撑AI落地,从零开始做AI很难适配大多数业务场景,平台转型要平衡新业务和原有生态的关系,不要盲目舍弃已有积累。

总:本文梳理了国内ToB SaaS领域头部平台钉钉的发展历程和当前存在的问题,呈现了国内企业服务产业的新动向和新问题,对产业研究有较高的参考价值,核心干货如下

1. 产业新动向:当前国内头部企业服务平台已经掀起AI原生转型的浪潮,钉钉推出悟空AI全面转向AI原生,是这一轮转型浪潮中的代表性事件,反映了国内企业服务赛道的最新发展方向。

2. 产业新问题:复盘钉钉的发展,暴露了国内ToB产业发展的多个核心问题:一是核心管理者变动容易导致战略彻底推倒重来,造成发展阶段断层,缺乏延续性;二是依附母公司的平台容易受到不匹配的KPI考核羁绊,不合理的考核会直接影响业务正常发展;三是AI转型存在脱离实际的误区,很多企业盲目All in AI,舍弃原有业务和生态积累,导致AI落地缺少底座支撑,多数通用场景都无法跑通。

3. 商业模式研究:本文梳理了SaaS生态平台的商业模式,测算出了成熟生态的收入空间,也明确了SaaS生态需要长期深耕的特性,为研究国内SaaS商业模式提供了真实的代表性案例。

声明:快读内容全程由AI生成,请注意甄别信息。如您发现问题,请发送邮件至 run@ebrun.com 。

我是 品牌商 卖家 工厂 服务商 平台商 研究者 帮我再读一遍。

Quick Summary

This article dissects DingTalk's current standing following the departure of former leader Wu Zhao, traces the development paths of DingTalk under three generations of leadership, and argues that DingTalk's most profound challenges are only just beginning. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Development history: Under first-generation leader Wu Zhao, DingTalk entered the office collaboration space from a management perspective. By recognizing that company managers are the key decision-makers for paid subscriptions, it stood out among a sea of competing products. However, this original positioning was inherently limited: it works well for micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) but fits poorly for large enterprise groups.

2. Strategic shift: When second-generation leader Bu Qiong took over, he transformed DingTalk from a single office tool into an enterprise service platform and built the initial framework of a SaaS ecosystem. But the ecosystem development was forced to halt when Bu Qiong stepped down before the framework could be refined.

3. Current status: After Wu Zhao returned to DingTalk, he discarded the original business and ecosystem layout and fully pivoted to AI with the launch of Wukong AI. By abandoning past development accumulation, the new AI initiative lacked a solid business foundation, making it difficult to roll out in most use cases. Wu Zhao then stepped down again. The new leader has now established a new organizational structure, but repairing the development gap and rebuilding the ecosystem will take a long time. The core pain point is that DingTalk's development has been marked by discontinuity and lack of strategic consistency: every acceleration is followed quickly by an abrupt halt.

This article presents a full retrospective of DingTalk's development journey, offering valuable insights on positioning, layout and transformation for B2B brands. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Brand positioning: Early on, DingTalk escaped homogeneous competition by carving out a unique niche targeting enterprise managers, the actual decision-makers for paid purchases, which helped it stand out from competing office software. This approach of precisely targeting decision-makers is a useful reference for brands. At the same time, brands must note the limits of this positioning: DingTalk's model only fits MSMEs and poorly serves large clients, so brands should clarify the boundaries of their target audience early on.

2. Ecosystem layout: The SaaS ecosystem business model offers enormous growth potential. In a mature SaaS ecosystem, for every $1 the platform earns, ecosystem partners can generate $6 to $8 in revenue. Based on this model, DingTalk's overall ecosystem revenue could exceed 20 billion yuan ($2.8 billion) once mature. However, building an ecosystem is a slow, detail-oriented process that requires continuous long-term investment and cannot be interrupted mid-progress.

3. AI transformation: AI transformation cannot be separated from a company's existing business and ecosystem accumulation. Unreasonable KPI setting can misguide business direction, and brands should avoid setting metrics that contradict business logic when pursuing AI transformation.

This article analyzes the lessons and experiences from DingTalk's development, offering key insights for sellers operating in the enterprise service sector. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Actionable insights: In the early startup stage, it is critical to target the correct paying decision-makers. DingTalk's success in escaping homogeneous competition by focusing on managers, who hold the budget for purchases, is a valuable reference for early-stage sellers. Building an open ecosystem also amplifies overall revenue: in a mature ecosystem, every 1 yuan of platform revenue drives 6 to 8 yuan in partner revenue, creating substantial long-term growth space.

2. Risks to avoid: Enterprises must maintain strategic consistency. Frequent strategic overhauls triggered by core leadership changes force companies to start from scratch, interrupting early accumulation and slowing overall growth. Unreasonable KPIs also mislead business direction: for example, DingTalk tied its AI business performance to token consumption, which ultimately led to hollowing out and poor implementation. Sellers must avoid setting metrics that contradict business logic.

3. Guidance for AI transformation: AI implementation requires existing business systems and ecosystem as a foundation. Starting AI from scratch by abandoning past accumulation makes it hard to fit most business scenarios. Transformation requires balancing new AI initiatives with existing capabilities.

This article analyzes development challenges of DingTalk as an enterprise service tool, offering key insights for factories pursuing digital transformation. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Guidance for digital tool selection: DingTalk's positioning shifted across different development stages. Early versions focused on meeting managers' oversight needs and fit small teams better, with poor adaptation for large enterprises. When selecting digital management tools, factories should assess fit based on their own scale and business requirements, rather than blindly choosing products that do not match their development stage.

2. Guidance for intelligent transformation implementation: Factories pursuing AI-powered intelligent transformation cannot separate the process from their existing business system foundation. All AI use cases require linkage and support from existing production, supply chain, ERP and after-sales service systems. Blindly starting AI transformation from scratch by abandoning existing business accumulation makes it difficult to deliver tangible results, and can even waste earlier investments.

3. Guidance for strategy implementation: Digital and intelligent transformation is a long-term project that requires consistent strategy and sustained investment. Frequent strategic interruptions and shifts waste earlier investments and make it hard to achieve expected outcomes. Factories should prepare for long-term investment and maintain strategic stability when advancing transformation.

This article reviews DingTalk's development history and current trends in the enterprise service industry, offering valuable reference for B2B enterprise service providers. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Current industry trends: AI-native transformation is now the core direction of the enterprise service track, and all leading platforms are investing heavily in AI products. However, a common pain point runs through this transformation: many leading platforms have pivoted to AI while detaching from their original ecosystem and business foundation, leading to poor AI product implementation and leaving large unmet demand in the market.

2. Underserved customer pain points: Enterprise customers now have strong demand for AI transformation, but AI implementation requires linkage across multiple business systems. Leading platforms without complete ecosystem support cannot meet this demand. Service providers can leverage their vertical-specific business system capabilities to partner with leading platforms, fill ecosystem gaps, and solve customers' AI implementation pain points.

3. Insights for cooperative development: The SaaS ecosystem is a mature business model for the future with enormous long-term value. In a mature ecosystem, every 1 yuan of platform revenue drives 6 to 8 yuan in partner revenue. Partnering with leading platforms unlocks greater revenue growth space for service providers. However, ecosystem building is a slow, meticulous process that requires preparation for long-term deep cultivation.

This article analyzes the lessons and experiences from DingTalk's development, offering strategic and operational insights for enterprise service platform operators. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. Strategic planning: Platforms must maintain strategic consistency. DingTalk has undergone three leadership changes, each accompanied by a massive strategic overhaul that interrupted continuous construction of its SaaS ecosystem and created major development gaps. Every acceleration is quickly followed by an abrupt halt. Platforms should avoid frequently discarding original strategies, value the continuity of past accumulation, and not fully negate all existing layouts lightly.

2. Operational assessment: Platforms must set KPIs aligned with business fundamentals. Early on, DingTalk was burdened with unreasonable KPI requirements for Alibaba Cloud resource consumption, which led to an overabundance of low-quality invalid customers and left it with persistently low paid conversion rates that have not recovered to this day. More recently, it tied AI business performance to token consumption, which does not align with the logic of AI implementation and led to AI business hollowing out. Platform KPIs must be rooted in business essence to avoid misguiding business direction through incorrect metrics.

3. AI transformation: AI transformation cannot be separated from the existing business foundation and ecosystem construction. AI implementation relies on support from mature ecosystem partners' business systems, and starting AI from scratch makes it hard to fit most business scenarios. Platform transformation requires balancing new initiatives with the existing ecosystem, and should not blindly abandon accumulated capabilities.

This article reviews the development history and current challenges of DingTalk, a leading domestic B2B SaaS platform, and presents new trends and problems in China's enterprise service industry, offering high reference value for industrial research. Key takeaways are as follows:

1. New industrial trends: A wave of AI-native transformation is now underway among China's leading enterprise service platforms. DingTalk's full pivot to AI-native with the launch of Wukong AI is a representative event of this wave, reflecting the latest development direction of China's enterprise service track.

2. New industrial problems: A retrospective of DingTalk's development exposes multiple core problems facing China's B2B industry: First, core leadership changes often lead to full strategic overhauls, creating development gaps and a lack of continuity. Second, platforms affiliated with larger parent companies are often constrained by mismatched KPIs, and unreasonable assessment directly disrupts normal business development. Third, there is a widespread unrealistic误区 in AI transformation: many companies blindly go all-in on AI by abandoning existing business and ecosystem accumulation, leaving AI initiatives without a foundation and unable to operate in most general use cases.

3. Business model research: This article sorts out the business model of SaaS ecosystem platforms, estimates the revenue potential of a mature ecosystem, and clarifies the characteristic that SaaS ecosystems require long-term deep cultivation, providing a real, representative case study for research on China's SaaS business models.

Disclaimer: The "Quick Summary" content is entirely generated by AI. Please exercise discretion when interpreting the information. For issues or corrections, please email run@ebrun.com .

I am a Brand Seller Factory Service Provider Marketplace Seller Researcher Read it again.

谁也没想到,一篇7.5万字的离职长文,硬炸出钉钉有史以来一个最大的瓜。而且从里到外,所有人吃得都很尽兴。

尘埃落定,钉钉这场风波看似已然落幕,一切即将回归正轨。

其实这只是假象。对钉钉来说,一场更加难以应对的深层挑战,才刚刚悄然登场。

说到处境窘迫、时间紧张,总爱用“留给XX的时间不多了”来形容。

但这句话,已经配不上现在的钉钉了。

如果只是时间所剩不多还好,而经历这次风波后的钉钉,所剩的时间“余额”,可能已经变成负数。

不但AI的冲刺之路又一次受阻,而更尴尬的是,钉钉再也回不到过去任何一个时代——回不到创业初期野蛮生长的“无招时代”,也回不到平稳发展的“不穷时代”。

很多人会问,为什么要往回看,直接向前冲不就行了?

但这恰恰戳中了钉钉最致命的痛点:发展阶段断层、缺少延续性,导致每一次提速冲刺,跑不了多远,就被迫踩刹车。

而这次的舆论风波,更是彻底印证了这一点。

01

站在管理者一侧,起家的核心底牌

看清钉钉的创业历程,不妨回头看看它最核心的立身之本。

和钉钉同期无数的办公软件,大多早已销声匿迹、淡出市场。而钉钉不仅活了下来,还一路做大做强,除了背靠阿里的资源优势,最关键的杀手锏,就是它独辟蹊径,从“管理者视角”切入办公赛道。

现在一说办公工具,大多反感偏向管理者、束缚员工的设计。但客观来讲,市面上绝大多数企业软件,底层逻辑都围绕“管理”搭建。从ERP、CRM到BI系统,无不站在管理视角,帮管理者洞悉全局、可视化组织、牢牢掌控业务,当然也包括人。

钉钉的特别之处,只是把这套管理逻辑,直接落地到“人对人”的层面,因而“管理属性”也更加突出。

其实背后的打算再简单不过:管理者就是买单人。

当然,任何切入点都自带局限性。靠“管理逻辑”起家的钉钉,对中小微企业、成长型团队适配度拉满;但这套打法放到大型企业、成熟集团体系里,就会显得格格不入。

这也导致无招的第一次出走。

02

不穷五年,留下未完成的资产

不穷接手后,做的最关键的推动,是把钉钉从单一的办公工具,升级成了覆盖多业务领域的企业服务平台。

而他留给钉钉最大的核心资产,并非只是产品迭代,而是搭建起了相对完整的SaaS生态。

这是另一个玩儿法——生态的商业模式。

与传统SaaS模式不同,除了丰富钉钉自有产品,平台生态还引入大量主流第三方SaaS产品与服务商,共同向各行业客户提供服务。

行业内有一个核心衡量指标:生态扩展率,用来衡量平台的收入带动力。成熟的SaaS生态的比例可达1:6~8,也就是平台厂商自身每赚1元,生态伙伴能赚到6至8元。

按照这套生态收入模型测算,想象空间足够大:如果钉钉生态能打磨到行业成熟水准,其自身ARR突破30亿时,整个钉钉生态的整体收入规模,就能轻松突破200亿。

但SaaS生态从来都是慢工出细活,极度耗费时间和资源。

全球顶级SaaS生态Salesforce,足足深耕二十余年,才打磨出如今成熟的生态体系。

可惜世界上没有那么多如果。

生态刚刚搭建雏形、尚未完全成型,五年后不穷卸任,钉钉的生态建设,也就此按下暂停键。

03

悟空:失去业务底座的AI冒险

无招的回归,让一切都彻底翻篇儿。

过往发展路径全部推倒重来,不论是钉钉原有业务布局,还是不穷时期搭建的SaaS生态,一定程度上都被搁置。

随着全面转向AI原生,钉钉悟空AI随之推出。

悟空的方向本身没有问题,但舍弃过往积累的代价太大了。

悟空缺少配套业务底座支撑,想仅凭大模型从零推理出业务结果,除了极少数业务领域(如法律服务),在绝大多数落地场景下,很难行得通。

以简单的电商退换货场景为例,仅靠悟空都很难实现。

因为整个过程需要OMS、WMS、TMS、ERP、支付、售后工单、会员营销等系统联动支撑,而脱离业务底座从零开始推理,就连退换货这种基础场景都跑不通。

当然,如果有生态伙伴业务系统支持,那就完全不同了。

正是生态底层与AI之间的这条巨大断层,让悟空这场AI转型,变成了惊险一跃。

或许无招原本已有补齐短板的解决方案,但随着他的再度离职,所有解法又都沦为没有答案的悬念。

04

置身阿里内,难以挣脱的KPI困局

无论是做SaaS、还是SaaS平台生态,其实只用两个KPI就足够了——ARR和NRR。

再多一个,都是羁绊,何况搞出跟ToB业务无关的KPI,更会直接把公司带偏。

早年推行云钉一体时,钉钉就背负阿里云资源消耗量考核,无效客户大量占用云资源,导致付费率持续低迷,至今都未能修复。

如今历史再度重演,Token消耗量又被纳入钉钉KPI。

其实,这件事本身就不合逻辑。

要知道,真正有效的AI,token消耗是极低的。因为大部分业务处理过程,都在底层SaaS业务系统中完成,并不需要重新推理。只有完全脱离业务底座、全靠模型从头推理的产品,才会持续消耗大量Token。

悟空如今落地难、业务空心化的现状,很难说没有这些KPI导向带来的影响。

05

钉钉的新脚手架

陈宇森接手钉钉后,很快给出了新的组织架构,这套布局,可以看作是钉钉用来破局的新脚手架。

相比无招拿了两把梯子就开始攻城,这套新脚手架看上去稳妥不少。至少从架构设计层面看,它考虑了解决AI业务空心化、落地难的问题。

但搭建好脚手架,和真正建成一座业务大厦,中间还隔着太多的未知变数。

比如,想要修复过往断层、重建生态,需要耗费和之前同等、甚至更长的时间。

而重新聚拢生态伙伴、恢复客户成功体系这类核心工作,全都无法一蹴而就。

所以,不得不说,钉钉真正的挑战,才开始。

注:文/戴珂,文章来源:tobesaas,本文为作者独立观点,不代表亿邦动力立场。

【版权提示】亿邦动力倡导尊重与保护知识产权。未经许可,任何人不得复制、转载、或以其他方式使用本网站的内容。如发现本站文章存在版权问题,烦请提供版权疑问、身份证明、版权证明、联系方式等发邮件至run@ebrun.com,我们将及时沟通与处理。

已点赞

+1

{{ praise_text }}

好文章,值得被更多人看到

广告

下一篇

跨境电商资源对接

《全球跨境电商服务商资源手册》第二期手册现已发布,触达更多资源,了解跨境服务商信息,欢迎点击链接下载。

了解详情

满意度下滑,Prime Day表现却仍超预期!期内美国电商GMV增至264亿美元

在6月23日至26日为期四天的大促期间,美国消费者线上消费总额达到264亿美元,同比增长9.3%。这一最终成绩不仅略高于Adobe此前263亿美元的预测值,也超过了更早前市场普遍预期的260.3亿美元。

北美 平台 国际电商 亚马逊

2026-06-30 13:45:28